Blog

A few days ago I had a conversation with one of my oil painting students. He had just got back from a painting workshop and anxiously said he needed to talk to me. He related how the workshop instructor made him question whether he should remain an artist. He asked me whether he should quit, that maybe he was just wasting time and art materials, and maybe he didn’t have enough talent to be an artist. The answer I gave him was not what he wanted to hear. I told him to quit. I knew he wanted my assurance that he was a good artist, and that he had talent and would make it as an artist. And here rotten bastard that I am I told him to quit. I didn’t coddle him I just said quit. Before you judge me too harshly and think that I was kicking him when he was down, please realize that I was being cruel to be kind.

I used to know a very gifted architecture student who got amazingly good grades in his architectural studies. Just as he was about to graduate a visiting architect gave a lecture at his school. The lecturer said in his lecture that at that time there was little chance of getting a job as an architect. Well, the student took this seriously and quit architecture. He believed the negative assessment, the opinion of this lecturer. He let the flame of desire in his heart to be an architect to go out. After graduation he drifted for a while never really finding another occupation that fulfilled him. However, what if he had said to himself after hearing the lecture, Damn it, I know it might be hard to become an architect, but I WILL become one no matter what. I will do what it takes until I become one. What buildings might he be creating and designing today? What sense of accomplishment would he be feeling?

So what kind of artist will my student become, if he says to himself: I don’t care what anyone says, I don’t care what roadblocks are in my way, I have a BURNING DESIRE to be a great artist and I WILL NOT STOP until I succeed. If he realizes that in the long run there is little difference between talent and perseverance. What wonderful paintings will he create if he keeps on keeping on. If he decides in his heart that it does not matter what that workshop instructor or I say. It’s what HE HAS DECIDED FOR HIMSELF that matters.

As artists we face many things that might make us want to quit making art. Maybe it’s a gallery rejection, an art show we didn’t get juried into, a slump in sales, a derogatory comment by a family member or a host of other things. It might help if we realize we are not alone in facing seeming roadblocks to our goal. If we look back in art history we find many artists have had challenges in their creative life. Winslow Homer quit painting for two years, after a painting that he felt was the best painting he could ever paint didn’t sell. Thankfully he dusted himself off and got back on the horse and went on to paint what many consider to be masterpieces of American art. Rembrandt went bankrupt in his 60s, Van Gogh was rejected by galleries and only sold one painting in his lifetime, Monet at times was close to blind, Renoir late in life had to paint with the brush tied to his hand. All these artists faced adversity, but they had one thing in common, THEY DIDN”T QUIT.

So now what about you?

 


The Fallow Field

"If one really loves nature, one can find beauty everywhere." 

Vincent Van Gogh

 

Recently I saw a Facebook post by an artist saying something along the line of why are so many artists painting a (excuse my French) a damn tree. I am familiar with this artist's work and he is a very good artist who often paints gritty city scenes. At first I was taken aback by his comment as I love to paint trees.  I also thought any subject matter could be fodder for great art. However it could also become an artistic cliche if handled thoughtlessly by a the artist. Trees could be rendered as generic cliches, and so could gritty city scenes, or even pensive young women in leather jackets or with tattoos leaning against brick walls. However, if any subject actually moves the artist and he/she conveys an authentic emotion in their painting then I feel he/she has created art. In other words it is not the subject matter of the work but was it painted authentically or not.

I love the paintings of George Inness, John MacDonald, Clyde Aspevig, David Hettinger, Richard Schmid, George Shipperly, Bruce Crane and many other artists who have often painted trees in their scenes of nature. I also love Jeremy Mann, Tibor Nagy and many other artists who often paint buildings and city scenes in their work. The common denominator in all the artwork I love, is the fact that I can see the artist's love for their subject.

Any subject matter can be starting point for a great work of art. Rembrandt painted a slab of beef at the slaughter house and did it with such feeling, amazing color and with such strong observation that it remains a major work of art centuries later.

It's not the subject it's the feel the artist puts into the work. If the artist lacks a strong feeling for the subject, and just paints for sales or recognition, or anything besides a love for the subject then that painting is inauthentic.

A tree painting can be authentic or inauthentic as can any subject.

 

Paintings are made by fools like me, but only God can make a tree. (with apopogies to Joyce Kilmer)

 

 

Worcester                                        Schmid                                                    Aspevig                                              Inness                                                


[WARNING: THIS BLOG POST MAY BE HIGHLY OFFENSIVE TO THOSE WHO IT REFERS TO, YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE, THE AUTHOR TAKES NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR YOUR HURT FEELINGS OR YOUR WASTED TIME.]

 

Recently, I have seen a plethora of marketing advice for artists that recommends that artists write newsletters and blogs, and articles and whatever. So many of us dutifully set aside our brushes and paints, or chisels and sit down in front of a computer and try and emulate Ernest Hemingway or Jane Austen. Then many of us post our musings in blogs and some of it gets spread throughout the multi-verse of the internet. Often picked up and spread by companies that market to artists with a bigger reach than the original blogger. Unfortunately, because of this push for artists to be writers, along with the good stuff written about art there is a whole lot of dreck being sent out. Written by people who have little more to say than if you mix yellow with red you get orange, or if you want to be successful you need to create a brand and network with others or worse yet, think positive. Only written because the artist has been told you have to be a blogger to be an artist.  Puhleeeze, everybody has already said these most of these kinds of things a gazillion times, and I don’t know about you, but when I get an email with this kind of content I hit the delete key faster than Michael Phelps can dive into the water. Why should anyone waste their time reading something by someone who has nothing new to say. Similarly, why should they waste their time on art that is inauthentic and a rehash of other artists work.  Mediocre artists create mediocre blogs when they can’t get any attention with their mediocre art. People who have done maybe three pieces of art in their life are now giving painting instruction on the internet or spouting off bromides like think positive. Also there is now a whole new crop of internet marketing gurus who for only $395 will allow you into their special master’s circle for secret advice about marketing art that nobody else knows. These people aren’t even artists but they sure know how to sell art or at least they know how to sell advice to the cadre of artists looking to find the magic trick that leads to being discovered. (Spoiler alert: Once you join the secret circle you’ll be told to blog.) It may sound like I am down on all blog posts and writings by artists, but I am really not. There are some artists who really do have something to say, but more and more they get lost in the deluge of drivel. Seek out the authentic writing by mature artists that are writing and painting with integrity, and you can get some real hard-won wisdom. Avoid the blogs by the artist who just took up painting two weeks ago and haven’t put in the time. Learn to separate the wheat from the chaff.

 


I recently received an email from a company that markets to artists special packages based on a well known artist's materials and techniques. The package consisted of a DVD, a book, several of the signature brushes the artist uses and a selection of his palette colors. The ad said that only 300 of these packages would be made so you needed to act quickly. I believe the intention of this company is to create a package that aspiring artists can purchase so they can paint exactly like Mr. Famous Artist. I found it somewhat amusing that people feel that if they just have the magic brushes and palette, and some DVD instruction that they could paint works close to the level of Mr. Famous Artist. It seems to me that even if you could paint exactly like Mr. Famous Artist you would just be a clone of him. You would not have the life experience of Mr. Famous Artist who created the style, but you would have possibly some of his techniques. So would the other 300 to 500 artists who purchase this package. I think it would be interesting when all these 300 artists would approach galleries, or competitions, or art shows with their cloned pieces all imitating the work of Mr. Famous Artist. There is nothing wrong with learning from other artists but trying to be a carbon copy of another artist is shortchanging yourself.  The world needs to see what you can paint, what you feel and how you uniquely express yourself, not how you can create close copies of another artist's style and technique. There are some artists whose work I've seen that have been so inspired by only one artist, that I can hardly tell their work from the artist they are inspired by. There is usually some clue, some slight lack of depth in the clones, but I will admit they can often come close to the original artist style. I think that just cloning another artist style and presenting it as your own is disingenuous because you did not go through the long period of gestation that the original artist did in developing a style. Hence, your work will never have the depth and quality of the original artist. Because basically it is not a unique expression of yours, but merely an echo of someone else's efforts. Another problem that I see is what I call workshop-itis. I've seen so many people attend so many workshops that they are totally confused, because one artist will tell them to do one thing, and the next workshop instructor who has a completely different style and medium probably will tell them to do another. It is often the case that were what works in one medium does not work in another. I've seen artists who attend a workshop in encaustic one weekend and a workshop in oil pastel the next, and a workshop in colored pencil the next. Instead of deciding to master one medium they bounce around from medium to medium, and instructor to instructor searching for that magic medium or palette, or collection of tricks that they feel make them a good artist. It's always on to the next medium or workshop in the search for the magical holy grail that will turn them into the artist that they always longed to be. Instead of this constant search  I would recommend that an artist study is much as they can in one medium and stay with that until they feel very, very comfortable with that medium. I believe that the only way to achieve a level of quality in your art is to focus. Learn the basics such as color theory etc., draw and paint a heckuva lot, learn from others but always follow your own path. After certain point, you need to take off the training wheels of following this or that current art fad, and explore the painting path on your own. Don't be taken in by the art supply industries latest gimmicky attempt to sell you something, but follow your own path, paint from your own center. I probably have this quote somewhat wrong, but I believe it was Krishnamurti who said "truth is the path-less land". Rembrandt is not remembered today because he was able to copy another artists style or technique, but because he followed his own path and created works that expressed his own unique inner vision.


Sargent's Teacher, Carolus Duran

Last night I was reading a book just before going to bed, which is something I like to do to calm my mind before sleep, when a sentence in the book jumped out at me. The line was: “Are you ready to add your creation to the catalog of man’s achievements.” The reason this sentence struck me was because of the belief that I always had that my work would not really be a major factor in the world of art history.  I probably would not be remembered like names like Monet, Van Gogh, Picasso, Rembrandt and others of their level of greatness. What I then realized was that even if my work did not seem to be major enough to be in the pantheon of the work of the master artists of the past it still contributed to the catalog of man’s achievements. That even though my work will probably never be exhibited at Chicago Art Institute, or the Tate, or the Guggenheim it still has importance to the people of my time who it resonates with. It is like one small tiny brick in the gigantic edifice which is art. Even if my/your work is not remembered you can never know the influence that your work could have on others. Many people know the name of John Singer Sargent, but how many know the name of Carolus-Duran, Sargent’s teacher? There are many artists in art history who got their start, or enhanced their knowledge from an art teacher or mentor whose name we don’t remember.  These teachers may not receive the acclaim or fame, but they too have added to the catalog of man’s achievements by helping another artist along on his path. We cannot know what the future holds, and one can imagine that Vincent van Gogh probably felt like a failure, and that his work would probably die with him. In his lifetime he was basically unknown, and only one of his works was purchased for the paltry sum of $20.  If anyone could have felt that he was an artistic failure and had not contributed to the catalog of man’s achievements, it would be Van Gogh. If he felt that way, we now can say in retrospect that he was wrong and he did add in a big way to the catalog of man’s achievements. Now please don’t get the idea that I am saying that if you are an artist, and nobody currently knows or cares about your work, that you’re going to be recognized in history like Van Gogh. However, what I’m trying to say is that you can’t be sure you won’t.  You also can’t know the influence you may have on other artists who may go on to become major figures.  The way Carolus-Duran influenced Sargent. So don’t get discouraged. Know that whether or not your work is lauded in the future you are part of the catalog of man’s achievements. Because you create.


Let me tell you little story, many years ago I was in Chicago Art Institute, I had already seen all the big impressive paintings by Rembrandt, Titian, Caravaggio etc. and I had just looked at J. M. W. Turner painting, when I turned into a slightly darkened hallway. There on the wall was a portrait of a man next to a portrait of his wife. It was by the artist Chardin. They were pastels, were very well executed. Since I’d already seen many masterworks as I roamed the halls of the Art Institute, the attraction as I moved closer to self-portrait was not the superb technique.  What was drawing me was a sense of humanity I was feeling coming through the work. I felt that even though Chardin lived maybe 400 years before me, I felt drawn  to his essence that came through his work. I realized then that art was magic. Here was a man who lived centuries before me who by taking ground-up earth, and mineral pigments and by rubbing them on a piece of paper had created his autobiography. I had a sense of his personality. I could see he had a kindly twinkle in his eye. I thought he would make a good neighbor. This is one of the first moments that I realized art is magic, and that one of the greater purposes of art was to express our humanity. When we approach our easels with our paints, our pastels, our watercolors, our charcoal or whatever medium we use, we are magicians.  We are creating a multi-dimensional world onto a two-dimensional surface. If the artwork we create is good it goes beyond mere technique, and has an underlying sense of what I like to call soul. Perhaps it is what we also call our humanity.  I’ve been recently reading a book called  “Scandals, Vandals and DaVincis” by Harvey Rachlin  which has a chapter about Henry VIII and Hans Holbein.  In the days of Henry the 8th there was no Skype or digital photography, so when Henry was looking for a wife he had no way of knowing what a prospect would look like if she lived in another country. So he commissioned Hans Holbein, who was the official court portrait painter, to travel to Italy to paint a portrait of an eligible Countess. Holbein created a masterpiece which delighted Henry VIII and gave him an idea of what his prospective wife looked like. I’ll let you read the book to find out how the romance went, but the important factor was not only did Holbein create a sense of the outward physical nature of the countess and her beauty, but he captured her sparkling personality and a sense of her soul. Art to be meaningful in my opinion, needs to go beyond just a photographic rendering. It needs to create a sense of beauty, timelessness, and humanity the way Holbein’s painting did. The way Chardin’s self-portrait did. I am hoping that in some of my work when looked at decades from now, some viewer will look at it and realize that the world of my time had its beautiful places and moments, and that this artist communicated some of that.  I also hope that when you approach your easel and you create your work, no matter what style you or medium you use, that your artwork communicates your sense of humanity and soul. Maybe some future viewer will get a sense of the essence of who you are, in the same way Chardin’s essence came through to me on that magical afternoon.  Chardin the conjuror.  


“Sometimes the highest form of action is inaction”.

Jerry Brown

 

I am currently working on the painting that is posted in this blog. I’ve been working on several days now and feel is coming along fairly well. I’ve been trying to capture the sky light on the trees coming through the foliage. I am also trying to create a sense of the feeling I get when in the Fox Valley near where I live. I feel this painting has a lot of potential but I’m not sure exactly if the painting needs more finessing or not, so what I decided to do is let it sit for a few days in my studio. A lot of times we artists want to complete a painting so we can move on to the next great idea we have. In a rush for closure on a painting we might makes some mistakes in judgment. Haste makes waste as the old bromide goes. I often urge my students while painting to stand back from a painting and look at it, and take a few moments to study it. Then they can come back and make revisions to it.  In essence, that’s what I’m doing with this painting, except I’m not just standing back from it for a few moments, I’m going leave it alone for a few days. I will then be able to review it with fresh eyes. Future Bill may see things that present Bill cannot. In other words will be several days of inaction, per Jerry Brown’s quote. In my own words, perhaps sometimes it’s better to take no action then the wrong action.


It’s not easy being green, as Kermit the frog once said, and it’s also not easy for an artist to paint greens in a landscape.

The other day at an artist group that I attend, one of the artists said that she was having trouble with green in her paintings, I suggested that she take green off her palette and mix her greens from the blues and yellows on her palette. Another artist in the group whose opinion I really respect, (because he’s earned his living as a professional artist for many years) said that if you’re having trouble with green you should not just carte blanche remove it  from your palette, but learn how to work with greens. He has given this advice before in other contexts where he recommended that if you had trouble with a certain aspect of painting to not to give up, but to work through the problem, and by working through the problem you would learn something that will help you in future paintings. I think there’s a lot of validity and wisdom to that advice. Don’t run from, or avoid using greens by limiting them from your palette, but learn how to effectively manage them. Usually when artists have trouble with green in their landscapes they make mistakes such as having a warm green where a cool green should be, or the chroma (saturation) is so strong that the green looks garish and creates an unreal look.

After thinking about my wise artist friend’s advice about green for several days, I decided that the thing to do was to figure out how you can add greens to your palette, without having the greens become unruly.  I know from my experience as a teacher that there are many students and artists that will have problems with green, if they add too many greens to their palette without a well thought out plan.

So while pondering the issue of green, and the multiplicity of greens available in tubes, I thought perhaps one way to work towards having several greens on  your palette might be to temporarily work with the split primary palette. A split primary palette could consist of a warm red such as cadmium red light, a cool red such as alizarin crimson, a warm yellow such as cadmium yellow medium, a cool yellow such as cadmium yellow lemon, a warm blue such as ultramarine blue, and a cool blue such as pthalo blue. You would for a while mix all your greens from the split primary palette. For example if you wanted a bright high chroma green, you could mix your cadmium yellow lemon with your Pthalo blue, and if you wanted a warm green you could mix your ultramarine blue with your cadmium yellow medium. If you wanted to mix a more neutral green, you could mix one of the two reds on your palette into the green previously mixed from blue and yellow.

After working with the split primary palette for a short while, you would develop an understanding of how to mix greens and how to neutralize them. Once this point is reached and you are comfortable with your green mixology, I would suggest adding a warm and cool green to your palette (for example sap green and viridian). After working with these two new greens and learning how to modify them you could add as many greens to your palette as your budget and size of your palette would allow. You could remove the artistic training wheels so to speak.

I am not saying that this solution is the only answer to the problem of green that an artist may have, but I do believe it is a workable progression for an artist toward a more comfortable relationship with the color green.

Any comments on this blog topic by those who have struggled with green on their palette and want to make suggestions that they feel can help other artists deal with green would be appreciated. Bye for now.


By way of full disclosure and since this is my first blog posting in decades, I confess that even though I teach landscape painting and can spot what a student needs to do to improve their work in about 20-30 seconds flat, I cannot do the same with my own work. I am like the roadside psychic who tells others what is going to happen in the future, but cannot predict a winning lottery ticket and hence is living in a shack. So to conquer some of my artistic blind spots I decided to see what other artists felt would make my work shine or at least look a bit better. I am very lucky that just such a group of artists were holding a critique on Saturday mornings at a local coffee shop. Great! Several of my addictions met at once, coffee, bagels and art talk. A trifecta. The icing on the cake is the group was founded and moderated by not one, count em,  but two nationally known artists. Because of this serendipity, I decided for this blog I wanted to discuss the pros and cons of such a assembly of creatives and why I feel a critique group has value for artists of any level.

 

First lets mention the cons:

1) It takes some courage to expose your work to criticism, even well meaning comments that are intended to be helpful.

2)One might think that this is painting by committee, and an artist to be true to their vision must always go it alone.

3) Not everyone in a critique group will always make a worthwhile comment since they are all on different points on the artistic path

 

and now the pros:

1) You are getting out of your head and your studio and actually meeting with people who are involved with the creation of art. Therefore you are talking with people who will have some understanding of what you are trying to achieve, more than the average citizen.

2) You will receive advice that just may take a painting from so-so to a hot diggity dog. Case in point, the painting that is pictured on this blog post was put in front of the critique group, and the trees went from just being there, to reaching up into the sky which really tied the sky to the foreground. I think it went from being just OK to a much better painting.

3) You will be exposed to other materials, techniques, processes and general art world info, like where a new figure drawing session is starting up or the location of that new gallery or where you can get a good price on some art supplies.

4) You might start feeling like artists can be normal with talk of families and such. Hmm, artists can be normal, Bill is an artist, therefore Bill is normal. Feeling better about myself already.

5) You might gain some humility, as you see the wonderful work other artists are doing.

6) You will break through that wall of fear (that is mentioned in con number one above), because you are doing the thing you fear which is exposing your work to scrutiny and you will realize you will survive to live another day. This conquering of fear will help you in the future when you venture out to send your work to galleries, enter a competition, or do a art fair.

7) You will learn that you can hear lots of advice, pick and chose what's useful to you and still keep your personal vision intact. Like Bruce Lee said "Absorb what is useful and disregard the rest". In other words, you will still be you, your work will still be yours and the "committee" can only make suggestions and you can still decide if they fit in with your vision for the piece or not.

8) You will learn to be graceful and tactful in responding to a not so helpful or artfully expressed comment. This is a skill that will be extremely useful in future encounters with gallery owners, potential art buyers or the person who tells you she has an aunt that can draw just like a photograph when she finds out you are an artist.

 

I think I have shown the positives outnumber the negatives of critique groups. I know there are some lone-wolf types who might disagree with me, but hey that is fine, if after reading this blog you don't feel a group is for you that's fine. In a future blog (if the interest is there) I will write about how I think you could get a critique group started in your neck of the woods if you don't have one currently available to you.