Blog

It’s not easy being green, as Kermit the frog once said, and it’s also not easy for an artist to paint greens in a landscape.

The other day at an artist group that I attend, one of the artists said that she was having trouble with green in her paintings, I suggested that she take green off her palette and mix her greens from the blues and yellows on her palette. Another artist in the group whose opinion I really respect, (because he’s earned his living as a professional artist for many years) said that if you’re having trouble with green you should not just carte blanche remove it  from your palette, but learn how to work with greens. He has given this advice before in other contexts where he recommended that if you had trouble with a certain aspect of painting to not to give up, but to work through the problem, and by working through the problem you would learn something that will help you in future paintings. I think there’s a lot of validity and wisdom to that advice. Don’t run from, or avoid using greens by limiting them from your palette, but learn how to effectively manage them. Usually when artists have trouble with green in their landscapes they make mistakes such as having a warm green where a cool green should be, or the chroma (saturation) is so strong that the green looks garish and creates an unreal look.

After thinking about my wise artist friend’s advice about green for several days, I decided that the thing to do was to figure out how you can add greens to your palette, without having the greens become unruly.  I know from my experience as a teacher that there are many students and artists that will have problems with green, if they add too many greens to their palette without a well thought out plan.

So while pondering the issue of green, and the multiplicity of greens available in tubes, I thought perhaps one way to work towards having several greens on  your palette might be to temporarily work with the split primary palette. A split primary palette could consist of a warm red such as cadmium red light, a cool red such as alizarin crimson, a warm yellow such as cadmium yellow medium, a cool yellow such as cadmium yellow lemon, a warm blue such as ultramarine blue, and a cool blue such as pthalo blue. You would for a while mix all your greens from the split primary palette. For example if you wanted a bright high chroma green, you could mix your cadmium yellow lemon with your Pthalo blue, and if you wanted a warm green you could mix your ultramarine blue with your cadmium yellow medium. If you wanted to mix a more neutral green, you could mix one of the two reds on your palette into the green previously mixed from blue and yellow.

After working with the split primary palette for a short while, you would develop an understanding of how to mix greens and how to neutralize them. Once this point is reached and you are comfortable with your green mixology, I would suggest adding a warm and cool green to your palette (for example sap green and viridian). After working with these two new greens and learning how to modify them you could add as many greens to your palette as your budget and size of your palette would allow. You could remove the artistic training wheels so to speak.

I am not saying that this solution is the only answer to the problem of green that an artist may have, but I do believe it is a workable progression for an artist toward a more comfortable relationship with the color green.

Any comments on this blog topic by those who have struggled with green on their palette and want to make suggestions that they feel can help other artists deal with green would be appreciated. Bye for now.


By way of full disclosure and since this is my first blog posting in decades, I confess that even though I teach landscape painting and can spot what a student needs to do to improve their work in about 20-30 seconds flat, I cannot do the same with my own work. I am like the roadside psychic who tells others what is going to happen in the future, but cannot predict a winning lottery ticket and hence is living in a shack. So to conquer some of my artistic blind spots I decided to see what other artists felt would make my work shine or at least look a bit better. I am very lucky that just such a group of artists were holding a critique on Saturday mornings at a local coffee shop. Great! Several of my addictions met at once, coffee, bagels and art talk. A trifecta. The icing on the cake is the group was founded and moderated by not one, count em,  but two nationally known artists. Because of this serendipity, I decided for this blog I wanted to discuss the pros and cons of such a assembly of creatives and why I feel a critique group has value for artists of any level.

 

First lets mention the cons:

1) It takes some courage to expose your work to criticism, even well meaning comments that are intended to be helpful.

2)One might think that this is painting by committee, and an artist to be true to their vision must always go it alone.

3) Not everyone in a critique group will always make a worthwhile comment since they are all on different points on the artistic path

 

and now the pros:

1) You are getting out of your head and your studio and actually meeting with people who are involved with the creation of art. Therefore you are talking with people who will have some understanding of what you are trying to achieve, more than the average citizen.

2) You will receive advice that just may take a painting from so-so to a hot diggity dog. Case in point, the painting that is pictured on this blog post was put in front of the critique group, and the trees went from just being there, to reaching up into the sky which really tied the sky to the foreground. I think it went from being just OK to a much better painting.

3) You will be exposed to other materials, techniques, processes and general art world info, like where a new figure drawing session is starting up or the location of that new gallery or where you can get a good price on some art supplies.

4) You might start feeling like artists can be normal with talk of families and such. Hmm, artists can be normal, Bill is an artist, therefore Bill is normal. Feeling better about myself already.

5) You might gain some humility, as you see the wonderful work other artists are doing.

6) You will break through that wall of fear (that is mentioned in con number one above), because you are doing the thing you fear which is exposing your work to scrutiny and you will realize you will survive to live another day. This conquering of fear will help you in the future when you venture out to send your work to galleries, enter a competition, or do a art fair.

7) You will learn that you can hear lots of advice, pick and chose what's useful to you and still keep your personal vision intact. Like Bruce Lee said "Absorb what is useful and disregard the rest". In other words, you will still be you, your work will still be yours and the "committee" can only make suggestions and you can still decide if they fit in with your vision for the piece or not.

8) You will learn to be graceful and tactful in responding to a not so helpful or artfully expressed comment. This is a skill that will be extremely useful in future encounters with gallery owners, potential art buyers or the person who tells you she has an aunt that can draw just like a photograph when she finds out you are an artist.

 

I think I have shown the positives outnumber the negatives of critique groups. I know there are some lone-wolf types who might disagree with me, but hey that is fine, if after reading this blog you don't feel a group is for you that's fine. In a future blog (if the interest is there) I will write about how I think you could get a critique group started in your neck of the woods if you don't have one currently available to you.